Category

Brain Basics

Featured
in Academic, Brain Basics, Critical

Slow Down: How To Make Time and Space For Focused ThinkingFeatured

This post explains why a busy, fast environment can hinder thinking in our children and explore how parents can provide time and space to think.

Slowing down is a low cost and high impact way to help your child practice focused thinking.

  1. Is your child too busy to think? An environment of hurry hinders thinking.
  2. Time and space for thinking can produce deeper engagement with a task.
  3. Try This [infographic]
  4. Takeaways

Too Busy to Think

Modern American culture glorifies “busy.” Our own lack of margin, as adults, can manifest in time pressures for our children. Rushing from activity to activity removes the open time necessary to focus, think, create, or innovate. Overscheduling can be exhausting not just physically but also mentally–children who are overscheduled are hindered in their ability to solve problems and make good decisions1.

An environment of hurry hinders thinking.

Between our adult agendas and our children’s schedules, down time could be called the new American Dream. Down time is needed more than ever, and more elusive now than ever.

Down time is critical because it provides opportunities for 1) play, 2) relaxation, and 3) connection1. These are essential ingredients for healthy brains:

  1. Play is a child’s “work”. Play allows experimentation, testing, and practice.
  2. Relaxation is an antidote to stress, which is important because stress blocks our access to the front of our brains (the prefrontal cortex) where more advanced thinking occurs.
  3. Connection is essential in grounding our children and knowing that they have a safe person with whom they can make mistakes and grow. Connection fosters resilience (capacity to endure hardship) and a growth mindset (ability to learn and grow with practice) in our children. 

Our fast pace can hinder our children when they lack opportunities for focused play, lack a physical environment to promote thinking due to stimulation and distraction, or when the fast pace leads us as parents to rush them through play and disrupt their focus.

Over time, our brains can become hardwired for fast and shallow thoughts rather than deep thinking or focused attention.

Our children—and us– need time and space to think.


Time and space for thinking can produce deeper engagement with a task.

Have you ever been so focused on a project, absorbed in a book, or captivated by a challenging problem that you became unaware of your surroundings? After being in this focused state, did you feel a sense of satisfaction in your work, or relief from common worries that occupy your mind?

In everyday life you might hear someone say they were “in the zone” at work. In modern psychological research, this is called hyperfocus, sustained attention, or even a “flow state.” (*See the end of this article for two important clarifications about the labels hyperfocus and flow).

Researchers describe flow as “full task engagement2” that involves absorption with a task and less thinking about oneself. There are a few key criteria: 1) the task is fun or interesting, 2) there is sustained attention, 3) the environment is diminished (time flies and you aren’t paying attention to your surroundings), and 4) task performance improves (you are able to do your work well).

While there is not consensus regarding which parts of the brain are specifically linked to hyperfocus (possibly a combination of attention networks)3, there are known benefits2 to flow:

  • stimulus of the reward system in the brain (positive emotions and satisfaction)
  • improved task performance
  • enhanced concentration

It is beneficial for our children to become engrossed in a task. And the most typical flow experience is play4! Children typically choose play tasks that are fun or interesting to them (the first criteria of flow), but whether or not they deeply immersive themselves in play depends on the child, the environment, and their capacity for sustained attention (typically increasing with maturity). As adults, we can’t always predict when our child will get “in the zone” for deep play, but we can create an environment that supports their concentration efforts.

Focused play is incredibly useful to our children both now and for their future endeavors. Think about the concentration needed to practice playing a new piece of music, or sit and think through a challenging LEGO® set, or construct a castle from wood scraps in the backyard. Later in life, they will need to focus and take exams, write papers, create presentations, and solve real-world problems in business, politics, the classroom, the operating room, the church, or wherever they choose to work and create.

Does your pace of life allow time for you and your children to deeply focus on something interesting? Can you lose yourself in a great book? Can your son lose track of time while he paints? Can your daughter tune out the rest of the world when she is coloring?


Try This

Making time for thinking provides opportunity for focused thinking. A physical space that promotes focused attention sets up our child’s brain for success. The parent’s role is to warmly support focused attention by watching and knowing when to encourage and when to hold back and resist interrupting.

Make time for focused thinking

  • When? Choose a gap between activities on your paper planner or Google calendar and leave that white space. Choose a time when your child is well rested and already fed. During that time, provide your child with a single open ended toy or specific task that can lead to immersive play. For example, provide only a train and set of tracks, or only a basket of building blocks.
    • Consider exchanging an extracurricular for open play, particularly in young children. “Even structured after school activities may take a toll on a child’s ability to stay engaged with one thing for as long as it takes to lose herself in it.5
  • How much time? As long as it takes for a child to lose themselves in one single activity. It is okay if the window of time is small at first. Aim for a few minutes at first and then encourage longer periods of play as the child’s capacity for sustained attention improves. Choose a realistic expectation (only a few minutes for very young children) and remember that their capabilities improve over time, not in one play session.

Make space for focused thinking

Our child’s environment (the physical place and the people around them) can promote or disrupt attention.

  • The physical place
    • A screen free environment is the best for building attention skills. Fast paced moving images and intuitive programming remove the workload from your child’s brain, and we want your child to think for himself rather than distracting from cognitive work with a moving image.
    • Decrease obvious sources of stimulation such as loud noises, music (unless it is classic or instrumental), or very bright lights.
    • Choose outside6 as often as possible. All children benefit from calming effects nature play, and even children with known attention deficits have shown fewer symptoms after time outdoors6.
  • The parent
    • School aged children may benefit from solitude, while younger children will likely benefit from having a parent nearby. Space for thinking does not always have to include solitude, which is sometimes unrealistic and does not reflect typical learning and play that occurs in pairs and groups in young children.
    • A parent’s involvement can positively or negatively impact a child’s attention.
      • Observe before you interrupt. When your child is working independently on a task and looks very focused, it may actually be distracting to verbally praise and interrupt.
      • Controlling how the child plays or intruding in play is counterproductive to building attention or independent thinking skills7.
        • In a study on focused attention in toddlers, researchers explored connections between mothers’ parenting and toddlers’ attention and found that a mother’s control of play was negatively related to attention scores:
          • “Although more active guidance may facilitate attention and play in infants and younger toddlers, parental behaviors that continue to reflect high levels of behavioral control or explicit direction and intervention can be inappropriate for more skilled toddlers, providing little support for children’s own natural tendencies to engage with objects and tasks in the environment and instead being disruptive or frustrating. For children who are already poorly attentive, parental interference may be particularly detrimental…7
        • The study also reported negative impacts of mothers intruding in play, such as “overwhelming the child with a barrage of stimulation, changing the focus of play without regard to the child’s interest, or physically manipulating the child or the child’s actions.7
      • In the same longitudinal study7, greater use of mothers’ praise during teaching tasks (not independent tasks) predicted higher attention and both mothers’ warmth (i.e. affectionate or supportive) and mothers positive affect (positive mood or expressions) were positively related to attention.
        • Essentially, mothers who were warm, positive, and encouraging at the right times were most beneficial for their child’s attention.

Takeaways

By providing time and space for our children to practice focused thinking (low cost), we encourage important cognitive skills (high impact)

Slowing the pace of life can create thriving little thinkers. Leave margin in life! Leave room for learning, exploration, creativity, or design. Give your child room to wonder. Leave space and time for curiosity.

If we fill the child’s schedule to the brim, where is the room for his thoughts? 

Providing margin in your child’s schedule may actually save you money if you choose to eliminate costs toward entertainment or schedule-fillers. Structured extracurriculars can be wonderful, but not if they dominate the schedule and eat all of your child’s margin for focused play. Talk with your spouse and your child about what activities to keep and which to try another time. Decreasing distractions in your environment does not incur costs. Taking your child outside also costs nothing, and greatly benefits attention skills. As the parent, you can support thinking as a supportive and warm observer (and encourager) of your child’s play. Your presence takes connection, not coin.

Downtime impacts our children’s brains and our family cultures. It provides opportunities for play, relaxation, and connection. Slowing down creates opportunities for learning. Hurry hinders thinking. A physical space that promotes focused attention sets up our child’s brain for success. A supportive, observant parent can positively impact a child’s attention. Children need to practice focused attention through play to build important skills for their futures.


Want to Learn More?

If you struggle with interrupting your child’s concentration during work or play, read How to Encourage Independent Thinking for a simple hack.

Does your child enjoy building? Practice focused attention using LEGO® bricks and build thinking skills in the process. Read 5 Ways LEGO® Bricks Promote Learning to find out more.


Two Clarifications on Flow and Hyperfocus

  1. Hyperfocus is often mentioned in the context of autism, schizophrenia, or ADD/ADHD in which attention is impacted by neurological changes, but hyperfocus occurs in neurotypical individuals as well (people with typical neurological development) and is incredibly useful2.
  2. To be clear, this flow state is specific to being absorbed in a task, so it is NOT the same use of “flow” used in eastern religion. It isn’t referring to zen, taoism or other attempts to empty the mind. It is task specific.

References

  1. Cleveland Clinic (2018). Is Your Child Overscheduled? Kids Need “Down Time” https://health.clevelandclinic.org/is-your-child-overscheduled-kids-need-down-time/
  2. Ashinoff & Abu-Akel (2021). Hyperfocus: The Forgotten Frontier of Attention https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7851038/pdf/426_2019_Article_1245.pdf
  3. Linden, Tops, & Bakker (2020). Go with the Flow: A Neuroscientific View on Being Fully Engaged https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7983950/pdf/EJN-53-947.pdf
  4. Csikszentmihaly (2014). Flow and the Foundations of Positive Psychology: The Collected Works of Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (ebook) https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-94-017-9088-8
  5. Perry (2009). Creative Kids Learn to Flow (Part 1) https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/creating-in-flow/200911/creative-kids-learn-flow-part-1?amp=#amp_tf=From%20%251%24s&aoh=16667956941485&csi=1&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com
  6. Lund (2018). Top 5 Benefits of Chldren Playing Outside. Sanford Health https://news.sanfordhealth.org/childrens/play-outside/ 
  7. Gaertner, Spinrad, & Eisenberg (2008). Focused Attention in Toddlers: Measurement, Stability, and Relations to Negative Emotion and Parenting https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2607062/pdf/nihms-81608.pdf
Featured
in Academic, Brain Basics, Critical, Resources

5 Excellent Books for Raising ThinkersFeatured

Did you know that one of the best ways to improve your child’s thought life is to improve your own?

When you demonstrate your own love of learning, you model for them what it could look like to love learning themselves. When you show them how to unwind with a great book at the end of the day, they learn to to value the written word and enjoy the process of reading and learning from good books.

Teachers, professors, instructors, and coaches typically receive ongoing training in their areas of expertise to help them be the best possible influence on their students and athletes.

The idea here is similar…you can improve your child’s mental game by improving your own.

Reading and learning for yourself, as a parent, increases your own thinking skills and is a low cost and high impact way for you to improve your child’s thinking skills. It’s a win-win.

Here is the list of 5 books I highly recommend for raising thriving little thinkers:

1. The Whole Brain Child by Daniel J. Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson

  • A great book about brain basics with specific strategies for promoting cognitive integration (using your whole brain). This book is written by the same authors as The Yes Brain. It is research based, well written, easy to understand, and clearly organized.
  • One favorite quote: “As parents become more aware and emotionally healthy, their children reap the rewards and move toward health as well. That means that integrating and cultivating your own brain is one of the most loving and generous gifts you can give your children.”

2. The Yes Brain by Daniel J. Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson

  • Another great book about brain basics. This book is helpful for providing specific strategies in building resilience and curiosity in kids. I don’t want my children to fear failure, or avoid mistakes. This book explains how to cultivate the right environment as the parent to promote the mindset we want our children to master. This book is written by the same authors as The Whole Brain Child and similarly research based, well written, easy to understand, and clearly organized.
  • One favorite quote: “What you do and don’t value, and what you do and don’t give attention to, will impact who your child becomes.”

3. The Read Aloud Family by Sarah Mackenzie

  • A great book about academic thinking and family culture, this one is helpful no matter what age your children are. Sarah Mackenzie crafts compelling arguments for cultivating a read-aloud environment in your home. She explains the academic benefits and the deepened relationships resulting from reading books together as a family.
  • One favorite quote: “When we read aloud, we give our kids practice living as heroes. Practice dealing with life-and-death situations, practice living with virtue, practice failing at virtue. As the characters in our favorite books struggle through hardship, we struggle with them. We consider whether we would be as brave, as bold, as fully human as our favorite heroes. And then we grasp—on a deeper, more meaningful level—the story we are living ourselves as well as the kind of character we will become as that story unfolds.”

4. Teaching from Rest: A Homeschooler’s Guide to Unshakable Peace by Sarah Mackenzie

  • Don’t let the word “homeschooler” lead you away from this book–replace the word “teaching” with “mothering” and you can quickly summarize the contents and apply it to your home. Sarah Mackenzie, the same author as The Read Aloud Family, writes beautiful words of encouragement for a mother who feels too much rests on your shoulders. While it is written from a homeschooling perspective, the concept of parenting and teaching from rest is applicable to any parent wanting to raise thriving little thinkers.
  • A favorite quote: “It’s easy to forget that teaching is holy work. We forget that building up the intellect- teaching our children to really think- does not happen by the might of human reason, but rather by the grace of God. On an ordinary day, you and I likely have a set of tasks we’ve scheduled for our kids. But it’s more than math. It’s more than history. It’s the building up of our children’s minds and hearts, and we can only do that if we realize that this is how we thank Him for the graces He so lavishly pours out on us.”

5. Awakening Wonder: Opening Your Child’s Heart to the Beauty of Learning by Sally Clarkson

  • I found this book to be more inspirational and beautifully written than practical. But the vivid picture of a child who loves learning has stuck with me and encourages me as I teach and train my children. Sally Clarkson describes her experiences teaching her own four children and how she created a culture of “wonder” and tried to create a “wonder-filled life.” It’s an excellent source of inspiration for those seeking to instill a love of learning in their families.
  • One favorite quote: “Education is not about enacting a prescriptive, boxed sort of curriculum-based classroom, but instead is about passing on a legacy of a love for learning, an independent joy in discovery, a motivation to bring light, beauty, and goodness back into the world of our children.”

A Note on Cost: While I’ve personally read all of the books listed, I borrowed them before I purchased them. My local library has excellent apps like Libby or Hoopla that allow me to listen to the audiobook for free or I can request hardcopies from within our local library system. I encourage you to utilize resources near you and get creative! If you prefer to purchase your own hardcopies to take notes or keep as reference, great! Just know that it isn’t required.

Featured
in Brain Basics

3 Ways That Adventures Change Our ThinkingFeatured

This post presents 3 important ways of thinking that are developed when our children experience appropriately challenging adventures.

  1. Does protecting your child from risk keep them safe?
  2. What kind of adventures?
  3. 3 ways adventures change our thinking
  4. What could this look like in real life?
  5. Try this today
  6. Takeaways

Does Protecting Your Child From Risk Keep Them Safe?

“Avoiding harm is essential to survival” but “overcoming risks is necessary to build resilient brains1” 

The words adventure and risk go together. It’s impossible to have a thorough conversation about how adventure changes our brains without acknowledging the elephant in the room: adventures carry inherent risk.  We have a parental responsibility (and innate desire) to protect our children from harm. For that reason, some parents may shy away from the idea of challenging our children. 

When thinking about taking your children to a new place or to try a new thing, you may have hesitations and “What ifs” that cloud your mind:

  • What if my child is uncomfortable? 
  • What if my child encounters a difficult problem? 
  • What if my child gets emotionally or physically hurt?

I’m going to respond with a few questions of my own…

  • WHEN (not if) your child experiences a difficult problem or uncomfortable situation, will he have confidence in his ability to navigate it successfully? 
  • Will she fear failure or embrace challenges as potential learning opportunities? 
  • Does your child know that he can do hard things? 

By appropriately challenging your children beyond their comfort zones, you are building their ability to thrive despite changing circumstances that they WILL inevitably face. Adventures encourage important types of thinking to help them navigate the stressful experiences they will undoubtedly encounter either in childhood, adolescence, or adulthood. “We tend to idealize childhood as a carefree time2but children may encounter problems ranging from adapting to a new classroom to navigating their parents’ divorce. “Add to that the uncertainties that are part of growing up in a complex world, and childhood can be anything but carefree.2” 

The bottom line–if we overprotect, we leave no room for them to grow.

Our children need to know and believe they can do hard things–and they learn their own capacity to do hard things by…successfully doing hard things! 


What kind of adventures?

Dr. Larry Brendtro defines adventure as “engaging in stressful activities with manageable risk.1He describes adventure on a continuum, just beyond play (fun and little stress or fear) but not reaching to the point of crisis (threat of physical or psychological harm). 

This is crucial–when I say that risk is good for our children’s brains, I am not saying we should put them in danger of major harm to their minds or bodies. I am suggesting that we choose appropriate challenges in supportive environments, with a supportive and engaged parent present.

When choosing an adventure for your family, think about what your children are currently capable of. You want to push them to try new things–which involves small amounts of stress that are manageable and even good—but you do not want to overwhelm them leading to high amounts of stress. Think Goldilocks here—not too much and not too little. Activities that provide just the right amount of challenge (good stress) can help our brains generate better recovery responses, retrieve memories from past experiences to apply to this situation, and generate new memories to add to their toolbox. 

Too little challenge? Not enough risk? Too much parent involvement? If the adventure isn’t stimulating, has no perceived usefulness, or doesn’t support autonomy, the brain will “downshift to lower order functioning.3” No risk, no gain. The brain isn’t going to spend energy on things it doesn’t perceive as important, useful, or interesting. 

Too much challenge? Too much risk? Not enough support? If the adventure is challenging beyond what the individual has the capacity to achieve, or if they feel that they do not have the support necessary to take appropriate risks, higher levels of stress will hinder ability to access parts of the brain that allow decision making and judgment. 

An adventure with your child can be as simple as a ride to a new grocery store, or as novel as a weekend camping trip. For your family it might look like a walk around the neighborhood or a short hike to a waterfall at your local state park. Personally, my first few trips to a local park with all three of my children, four years old and younger, felt like major excursions until I grew more comfortable.

An adventure is any opportunity to get your child out of their normal routine, respond to a new environment or situation, and build their adaptability. Adventures don’t have to be outside, but there are special benefits to outdoor environments.4

The “best” adventures3:

  • Differ from our everyday normal (provide novelty)
  • Offer just the right amount of challenge (not too easy or overwhelming)
  • Provide opportunities for both failure and success
  • Involve personal support and safety (you—the present, responsible adult)
  • Engaging and perceived as useful for the child(ren)
  • Provide open ended challenges and promote choice (autonomy and independent thinking)

3 Ways Adventures Change Our Thinking

By providing adventures (challenges) for our children, we are helping them change their thinking in three different ways that will help them thrive throughout their lives: self efficacy, resilience, and reflection.

  1. Self Efficacy
    • Self efficacy is a person’s belief in their competence to execute a specific behavior or achieve a particular goal5
    • Self efficacy is developed in a child who believes they have the capacity to achieve a goal. It provides an optimism and confidence, based on a personal assessment of skills and capacity, that intrinsically motivates a child to try something new.
    • While self efficacy may sound like self esteem, the two are not the same. Self-esteem is an overall regard a person has for themselves and more often associated with a general attribute of confidence. Self efficacy is a belief specific to a behavior or goal. 
  1. Resilience
    • Resilience is successful adaptation (mental, emotional, or behavioral) to challenging experiences and internal or external demands.6
    • What happens in the brain? “…resilience may be explained by the brain’s innate capability to adapt its structure (growth of new cells) and function (re-wiring of existing cells) directly in response to environmental exposure.3
    • Resilient thinking is when a child tells themselves that even if they don’t succeed or achieve a goal, they will be able to adapt and find a new way of thinking. Resilience helps the child to know what failure looks like, to learn from it, and apply their learning to the next problem they encounter. When they find mistakes to be learning opportunities, they can try new adventures without fear of failure. 
    • Adventures will not always go as planned. “The goal is not to eliminate emotional ups and downs in a child’s life, but to understand that these ups and downs are normal and can be dealt with.4
  1. Reflection
    • Reflection is thinking about an experience, evaluating it, and synthesizing the learning that occurred. Reflection is an important metacognitive skill (awareness of your own thinking) that leads to self discovery of strengths and weaknesses.
    • What happens in the brain? Providing time for explanation or time for quiet thinking allows the new experience “to be absorbed as new brain cells are created and neural pathways strengthened.3”  Reflection, making sense of the adventure, can have more impact on building resilience than the actual experience itself.3
    • We want an open, growth view of a child’s capabilities during self assessment. We don’t want fear of failure or risk avoidance. 
    • Use reflective thinking prompts:
      1. What went well? 
      2. What would you do differently next time?

What could this look like in real life? 

Let’s imagine an example: You plan a Saturday morning adventure to your local state park. On a short hike, you point your child toward a log that has fallen across a creek and made a “cool bridge.” You keep a positive, upbeat tone and ask, “Do you want to cross it? I’ll be right here if you need me.” 

 Let’s consider the types of thinking that could be built through this adventure:

sample thoughts of self efficacy, resilience, and reflection

Try this today: ways to challenge your children through adventure

  • Know your Child.
    • Knowing your child is the best way to provide the right opportunities for them to try something new, with just the right level of challenge that will inspire and not overwhelm them. Daniel J. Siegel, MD and Tina Payne Bryson, PhD, co-authors of the book The Yes Brain: How to Cultivate Courage, Curiosity, and Resilience in Your Child, describe the importance of knowing when your child needs “pushin’ or cushion.7The only way to know whether to push or back off is to have a great relational foundation with your child that includes security and safety.
    • As their parent, you are in the perfect position to know your child, how they learn, and how they operate. 
  • Model it and say it.
    • Children see and follow. The best way to change your child’s behavior is to change your own. Let them see you persisting in goals even when you encounter an obstacle. Say it—verbalize your frustration at the obstacle and as you strategize another way to accomplish your goal, say your thoughts out loud to make these abstract ideas more tangible for your children. When you offer specific praise after they encounter a challenge, verbalize what you saw them do, emphasizing effort and strategy over success. 
      • A note—you don’t have to have a lecture or hours long session in which you bombard your child with questions and thoughts about how they “jumped off that rock so well.” Too many words can be counterproductive. But keep a watchful eye on them as they attempt a challenging feat and think about simple ways to reinforce these important types of thinking. It can even be better to say nothing, and let the personal reflection in their minds do the teaching. Often, the experience speaks for itself. 
  • Don’t fear risk.
    • Appropriate risk is not the same thing as neglect or putting your child in harm’s way. It’s natural and necessary for survival to want to protect your child, but navigating challenges is how your child learns to endure and thrive. Get out there! Keep your eyes out for possible challenges and adventures. 

Takeaway:

Adventures are a low cost and high impact way to change your child’s brain.

The best adventures are often free. They will involve time and presence, but do not require your savings account. These are low cost and high value experiences.

Local, state and national parks, nature centers, factory or farm tours,  a camping trip, a challenging new science project, or even a volunteering experience that pushes cultural boundaries can all accomplish the goal of pushing our children to navigate manageable risk and discomfort. 

The point of encouraging adventures and challenges for your family isn’t to spur guilt spending or booking an adventure vacation with pricey excursions. If you have the finances and time and teenagers who want to learn to scuba dive—go for it! But know that it isn’t necessary. That’s just icing on the cake.

Experiencing appropriately challenging adventures with your child is an impactful way to create memories and build important thinking skills.

By providing adventures (challenges) for our children, we are helping them build thinking skills in three different ways that will help them thrive throughout their lives: self efficacy, resilience, and reflection.

Children of all ages benefit from intentional, occasional deviations from routine. Adventures remove us from our “normal” comforts and help us to actively engage in new experiences. Exploring new environments, trying new skills, and navigating risks all have direct impacts on developing brains. In fact, our incredible brains can even re-wire and adapt in response to changing environments. 

By appropriately challenging your children beyond their comfort zones, you are building their ability to thrive despite changing circumstances. You are building up important brain skills (also known as cognitive skills) to help them navigate the stressful experiences they will undoubtedly encounter either in childhood, adolescence, or adulthood. 

Our children need to know and believe they can do hard things–and they learn their own capacity to do hard things by…successfully doing hard things! 


Subscribe to TLT’s free monthly newsletter

for exclusive brain based ideas


References

  1. The Dueling Needs for Safety and Adventure 
  1. Resilience Guide for Parents and Teachers
  1. Brain resilience: Shedding light into the black box of adventure processes
  1. Nature Preschools and Forest Kindergartens: The Handbook for Outdoor Learning
  1. Self Efficacy: Helping Children Believe They Can Succeed
  1. Resilience
  1. The Yes Brain: How to Cultivate Courage, Curiosity, and Resilience in Your Child
Featured
in Brain Basics, Critical

How to Encourage Independent ThinkingFeatured

This post describes a physical and mental exercise for parents and children, called “looking hands” to enhance independent thinking and problem solving.

  1. Put your hands behind your back.
  2. Why is it useful to keep our hands to ourselves?
  3. Try This Today: 3 ways to try “looking hands” in your home today
  4. Takeaway

Put your hands behind your back.

When my daughter was a toddler, she was eager to explore her surroundings. Everything was new and exciting and she wanted to touch, feel, smell, and taste it all. While this is developmentally appropriate and I wanted to encourage exploration—there are some things that just are not safe for a toddler to explore (i.e. breakable objects like glass, sharp knives, etc.) For those items I would say “Use your looking hands” and she would put her hands behind her back and focus on exploring with her other senses. We would talk about whatever the object was, describe it, and explore it without physically touching it. 

I honestly trained my children to use looking hands because I needed them to keep their hands to themselves. It was for their safety, yes, but also for my productivity and efficiency. If I could do something myself without interference, it would be done more quickly and correctly with less mess.

I began to learn that while there may be less mess when I take over, there is less learning happening, too.

While teaching nursing clinical students in a neuro ICU, I was observing a student prepare a medication and saw her fumbling. I reached over to help but she politely and firmly said “I’ve got it, Dr. Mumbower.” She was right! She NEEDED to fumble and try again so that she could learn and have the muscle memory to perform the skill next time. She needed me to observe and coach, not take over and micromanage.

I did not expect looking hands to be something that would help me as the adult. I realized that I needed to put my hands behind my back, too. I need to use “looking hands.”  

I began putting my hands behind my back into looking hands position whenever I was observing a student so that I could give myself time to observe and think before interrupting their concentration or necessary fumbling. When students were new or needed more hands on help, I would simply say “I’m here when you need me.” And when students were competent and clearly ready to perform, I would say “I’m just here as backup. You’ve got this.” 

My student’s polite and respectful comment led me to consider what I appreciated most about the many “coaches” or instructors I had over the years. The ones I felt the most discouraged by were the ones who micromanaged or rushed me or “took over for me” because I was trying to figure things out or pause and check over my work. The ones I appreciated the most were the ones who assessed my ability and then stepped back and let me practice. They gave feedback and let me try again. 

Looking hands is now part of my parenting, not just part of my clinical teaching. I use looking hands when I am tempted to rush my toddler through putting his shoes on, or when I am tempted to interrupt my daughter’s question of curiosity about a new book and tell her the answer for the sake of expedience. Looking hands is a physical reminder to put myself in the position of a coach, and to act accordingly.


Why is it useful to keep our hands to ourselves?

When we use our “looking hands” with our children, and learn the art of when to step away and say “You’ve got this,” we build their self efficacy. Self efficacy is a person’s belief in their competence to execute a specific behavior or achieve a particular goal. Self-efficacy is not self-esteem (a general regard a person has for themselves) nor a general attribute of confidence. It is gained by doing a skill over and over, again and again. 

Using your “looking hands”–putting your hands behind your back–when your child is trying an activity can be a low cost and high impact way of helping them learn to think and practice on their own. Yes, they will make a mess. Yes, it will take longer than if you do it for them. But the goal isn’t perfection. The goal is independent practice. 


Here are 3 ways to try “looking hands” in your home today:

  1. While teaching or training
    • After modeling how to perform a task, give your child a turn and use your “looking hands” while they work. Do not interfere unless they ask for help and try verbally coaching instead of physically interfering with their practice. Show your child how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and then step back and let them try on their own. 
  2. While playing
    • When working with a puzzle or toy, avoid the impulse to show them the solution and use your “looking hands.” Allow them to try different pieces and problem solve. If they ask for help, try verbal coaching toward the next step rather than completing the task for them.
  3. While talking
    • With an older child or teenager who faces a conceptual problem (like a breakup or friend drama) and not a physical problem, use the idea of parent “looking hands” and try not to jump in and “fix” the problem. Empathize and then talk with them through potential next steps toward a solution. You can physically place your hands behind your back in the “looking hands” position to help you remember that you are coaching, not doing things for them.

TAKEAWAY

Taking over for our children doesn’t allow them the freedom to think, fail, and try again. While letting our children think through tasks or problems is more time consuming and potentially more messy, it’s critical to allow them to fumble and try. Put your hands behind your back. Conquer the urge to interfere or micromanage. Coach them–don’t complete it for them. Learn the art of when to step away and say “You’ve got this.” The goal isn’t perfection. The goal is independent practice.

For exclusive brain-based tips on raising thriving little thinkers, subscribe to my monthly newsletter below

Close